The Institutional Review Board's conference room was quieter than Wren had anticipated.
It was the kind of stifling quiet where everyone remained perfectly polite, restrained, and monotone, yet absolutely no one was on your side.
Seven panel members sat across the long table—experts in medical ethics, data security, clinical administration, and legal compliance. Each had a copy of Stellaris's supplemental files in front of them. The soft rustling of turning pages echoed in the room, cutting through the silence like tiny blades.
Wren sat in front of the projector, her thumb resting on the laser pointer.
She had only slept for two hours the night before.
The minor protection protocol had been rewritten three times, the data revocation workflow was now mapped out visually, and the post-op follow-up consent forms had been split into standard and specialized demographic versions.
She thought she had at least earned a step forward.
But the Board Chairman flipped to the final page and asked a single question: "Ms. Whitaker, how can you guarantee that patients truly comprehend what they are consenting to?"
Wren looked up.
"We provide verbal explanations, written documentation, and a mandated cooling-off period prior to authorization. Patients can revoke consent at any stage. Once revoked, their data immediately enters a anonymized lockdown protocol and is permanently excluded from future model training."
Her response was unshakeable.
It was the most airtight answer possible from a technical and systemic standpoint.
The Chairman nodded. "I've reviewed the workflows."
He closed the folder.
"But I'm not asking about the workflow."
A heavy silence descended upon the room.
Sitting beside Wren, Phoebe's pen froze.
Wren met the older man's gaze. "What exactly do you mean?"
"I mean that when a patient is confronted by a doctor, a massive medical institution, and a complex system they can't possibly understand, it is exceptionally difficult for them to freely say no," the Chairman explained. "You can offer them a revocation button. You can make them sign an informed consent form. But they might never truly grasp the implications of refusing, or the reality of agreeing."
Wren's grip on the laser pointer tightened.
It wasn't that she hadn't considered this dilemma.

VERIFYCAPTCHA_LABEL
Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: Sign the Papers Mr. Langford